Stephen Grosz’s (b. 1952) The Examined Life is the primary inspiration to my eponymous site. Not only for name—which I humbly copied—but for purpose: to bring narrative, personhood, and meaning to the wonderfully human process of striving and settling, hating and loving, struggling and finding peace.
At one time or another, most of us have felt trapped by things we find ourselves thinking of doing, caught by our own impulses or foolish choices; ensnared in some unhappiness or fear; imprisoned by our own history. We feel unable to go forward and yet we believe that there must be a way. ‘I want to change, but not if it means changing,’ a patient once said to me in complete innocence. Because my work is about helping people change, this book is about change.
Grosz believes, as do I, that self-knowledge leads us through difficult roads, silent forests, avenues without end. That we must face wayward darkness in order to reconcile pain with peace.1
Grosz has been a practising psychoanalyst for almost three decades. He is based in London. The Examined Life collects and connects some of his most memorable cases.2
“How we can be possessed by a story that cannot be told” is a story of a patient who acted out—even going so far as to fake his own death—from an inability to articulate his pain and fear. Grosz concludes:
Experience has taught me that our childhoods leave in us stories like this—stories we never found a way to voice, because no one helped us find the words. When we cannot find a way of telling our story, our story tells us—we dream these stories, we develop symptoms, or we find ourselves acting in ways we don’t understand.
In a story of a compulsive liar who lied profusely to keep himself safe, Grosz again helps us see beyond the behavior to the motivation:
“I used to wet my bed as a child, Philip told me. He described crumpling up his damp pyjamas and pushing them deep into the covers, only to find them at bedtime under the pillow, washed and neatly folded. He never discussed this with his mother and, to the best of his knowledge, she never told anyone, including his father, about his bedwetting. ‘He’d have been furious with me,’ Philip said. ‘I guess she thought I’d outgrow it. And I did, when she died.’
Philip’s lying was not an attack upon intimacy—though it sometimes had that effect. It was his way of keeping the closeness he had known, his way of holding on to his mother.
When a father cuts off his daughter for marrying outside her faith, Grosz works with his patient to understand it was likely her father’s own guilt at an extra-marital affair that drove his torrential judgement.
Psychoanalysts call this ‘splitting’—an unconscious strategy that aims to keep us ignorant of feelings in ourselves that we’re unable to tolerate. Typically, we want to see ourselves as good and put those aspects of ourselves that we find shameful in another person or group. Splitting is one way of getting rid of self-knowledge.3
In “How lovesickness keeps us from love,” Grosz works with a patient to understand how being intensely sentimental can keep us from feeling true emotions.
Many psychoanalysts think that lovesickness is a form of regression, that in longing for intense closeness, we are like infants craving our mother’s embrace. This is why we are most at risk when we are struggling with loss or despair, or when we are lonely or isolated—it is not uncommon to fall in love during the first term of university, for example. But are these feelings really love?
Among many stories that feel achingly familiar, my particular favorite is a tender story on how the fear of loss can make us lose everything.
We are vehemently faithful to our own view of the world, our story. We want to know what new story we’re stepping into before we exit the old one. We don’t want an exit if we don’t know exactly where it is going to take us, even—or perhaps especially—in an emergency. This is so, I hasten to add, whether we are patients or psychoanalysts.
I want to type up the entirety of Grosz’s The Examined Life and share it with you. It is one of the most comforting, inspirational, and enlightening books I’ve ever read.4
And yet The Examined Life it is a difficult book.
Each time I read it I find myself wishing for a Stephen Grosz in my life. That person who would see and understand me. Write my story. I read somewhere that is why we marry, to engage a witness to our lives.5
We all long to be seen and loved for who we truly are. That is what Stephen Grosz’s The Examined Life is about. It is what my Site is about.
Find that person who can understand you, seek them out and hold on. Or, even better, be that person to others. Can we as humans aspire to anything greater?